Dedicated to Empowering and Informing the Burlingame Community

I hope you aren’t following the dog poop bag controversy too closely. At least double arm’s length works. Since it’s mostly NextDoorish content, I wasn’t going to add to the kerfuffle although I did like the student idea of different colored stickers to show your willingness, or lack of same, to dog owners using your bins along the walk. Of course, the stickers would be promptly ignored, but it is a fun idea, nonetheless. Now local Pastor Pete Garrison has delivered a philosophical treatise on the stinky question in a letter to the DJ.


The letter on Monday from Peggy Charlton Brady poses an interesting metaphysical question. “The question, then, is whether one properly tied dog-waste bag somehow becomes inappropriate simply because someone else placed it there.” In Thomistic-style (Ed i.e. Thomas Acquinas), I will pose three objections.

1). The bag becomes inappropriate because of the action of someone else.

2). The bag becomes inappropriate because of where it is placed.

3). The ownership of the black cart makes the bag inappropriate.

Answer one. The appropriateness of the bag is not affected by the action of someone else whether that action is inappropriate or appropriate. The bag simply is.

Answer two. The appropriateness of the bag is not affected by the place where it is placed. The location and bag simply are together.

Answer three. The bag’s quiddity* is unaffected by the actor’s address.

So, I answer that Ms. Brady is correct in noting that the black cart is simply a container into which a dog-waste bag may be placed. Thus, there can be no value of “appropriateness” assigned to the dog-waste bag put in a black container. Hope this helps.

Peter Garrison

*quiddity – the essential nature or defining quality that makes something what it is. (I had to look it up)

So dear readers, did that help? Seminary school wasn’t wasted. I’m just glad when the canine’s companion cleans up after the canine regardless of where the bag is deposited–just not the blue bin. Perhaps Peter can add a 4) about recyclability appropriateness.

Posted in ,

Leave a Reply


The Burlingame Voice is dedicated to informing and empowering the Burlingame community.  Our blog is a public forum for the discussion of issues that relate to Burlingame, California.  Opinions posted on the Burlingame Voice are those of the poster and commenter and not necessarily the opinion of the Editorial Board.  Comments are subject to the Terms of Use.


All content subject to Copyright 2003-2026