Burlingame Voice co-founder and editor Russ Cohen has this to say about the project on the Bayfront:
There is currently a proposal regarding a bayside park including a nature preserve, access to the bay and an large event space. Besides the details of the proposal, which are vague at best, consider the operations of the venue. Your first consideration is The SPHERE Institute itself. While they are the entity presenting the proposal, they are also the operator. They have admitted that they’ve never done anything like this before. Their mission statement has nothing to do with nature preserves, wetlands restoration or running an event venue. This should be a concern for all of us who live in Burlinagame.
This park will be operating in our city but the city will have no control over its operation nor its success (or failure.) This too should be a major concern.
For example, the hours of operation have changed several times, the types of events held have not been defined. The noise from these events, the inadequate parking and the light pollution have not been fully considered. Just because this project is on the bayfront does not mean the effects of this project will not be to the detriment of the neighborhood directly to the west of it. To my knowledge, no environmental studies have been done. Has BCDC rendered an opinion?
The land’s owner, The State Lands Commission, is not mentioned on the operating plans. This begs the question, “How will success be measured and monitored? And what happens if it doesn’t meet the criteria for success?” Who is left holding the bag? Who will step up if this project has a shortfall? Will the land return to a fallow 10 acres and sit for another 40 or 50 years as it already has, becoming an underutilized property along the Burlingame Bayfront?
Years ago, the city entered into a lease agreement with a private company to manage the Golf Driving Range where Top Golf is today. The revenues were inadequate and closure was eminent. A new very favorable lease with a new operator was agreed upon in order to keep the doors open. The lesson here is that the city could control the outcome to a certain degree. The Bay Rise Park project, on the other hand, eliminates the city from influencing the project in any way, instead SPHERE will operate by its own rules and standards with no city oversight. This should be a red flag for our city. At the very least, an oversight committee should be considered.
Perhaps the question should be, “Who is The SPHERE Institute? According to a search on the internet its budget has been as high as $38 million in 2021, its CEO makes $640K per year. What’s difficult to find is where the funding of the institute comes from in the first place.
Another obvious question is, why do they want to embark on a project like this that they have zero experience with and are looking to fund the operation, not out of their annual budget, like some of their other endeavors, but rather fund it through the leasing of a building on the grounds of Bay Rise Park? It’s important to some that the funds that will help to make this park a reality aren’t subject to disappear depending on the winds of change. Has anyone asked these questions before shaking hands on an agreement?
To date, to my knowledge, there has not been a pro-forma presented. How much will it cost to build and operate? How much revenue will the event center have to generate and how often would it have to be rented in order to cover the annual costs? Projected numbers are important. The fact that this project has been in the development stages for 7 years without any real projected numbers may indicate that SPHERE is ill-prepared to operate such a magnanimous effort.
The restoration of our wetlands, the improving of access to the bay and education for the public and more open space to enjoy all sound good. But, it can all go sideways very quickly if we don’t ask the tough questions, even at this late stage of the project’s development.
Someone, the press, the state lands commission, the state treasurer, the state attorney general? Someone needs to look into who SPHERE is or it may be too late. Here is the proposed building.



Leave a Reply