Dedicated to Empowering and Informing the Burlingame Community
Of Bins and Dog (poop)
I hope you aren’t following the dog poop bag controversy too closely. At least double arm’s length works. Since it’s mostly NextDoorish content, I wasn’t going to add to the kerfuffle although I did like the student idea of different colored stickers to show your willingness, or lack of same, to dog owners using your bins along the walk. Of course, the stickers would be promptly ignored, but it is a fun idea, nonetheless. Now local Pastor Pete Garrison has delivered a philosophical treatise on the stinky question in a letter to the DJ.
The letter on Monday from Peggy Charlton Brady poses an interesting metaphysical question. “The question, then, is whether one properly tied dog-waste bag somehow becomes inappropriate simply because someone else placed it there.” In Thomistic-style (Ed i.e. Thomas Acquinas), I will pose three objections.
1). The bag becomes inappropriate because of the action of someone else.
2). The bag becomes inappropriate because of where it is placed.
3). The ownership of the black cart makes the bag inappropriate.
Answer one. The appropriateness of the bag is not affected by the action of someone else whether that action is inappropriate or appropriate. The bag simply is.
Answer two. The appropriateness of the bag is not affected by the place where it is placed. The location and bag simply are together.
Answer three. The bag’s quiddity* is unaffected by the actor’s address.
So, I answer that Ms. Brady is correct in noting that the black cart is simply a container into which a dog-waste bag may be placed. Thus, there can be no value of “appropriateness” assigned to the dog-waste bag put in a black container. Hope this helps.
Peter Garrison
*quiddity – the essential nature or defining quality that makes something what it is. (I had to look it up)
So dear readers, did that help? Seminary school wasn’t wasted. I’m just glad when the canine’s companion cleans up after the canine regardless of where the bag is deposited–just not the blue bin. Perhaps Peter can add a 4) about recyclability appropriateness.
Burlingame Voice co-founder and editor Russ Cohen has this to say about the project on the Bayfront:
There is currently a proposal regarding a bayside park including a nature preserve, access to the bay and an large event space. Besides the details of the proposal, which are vague at best, consider the operations of the venue. Your first consideration is The SPHERE Institute itself. While they are the entity presenting the proposal, they are also the operator. They have admitted that they’ve never done anything like this before. Their mission statement has nothing to do with nature preserves, wetlands restoration or running an event venue. This should be a concern for all of us who live in Burlinagame.
This park will be operating in our city but the city will have no control over its operation nor its success (or failure.) This too should be a major concern.
For example, the hours of operation have changed several times, the types of events held have not been defined. The noise from these events, the inadequate parking and the light pollution have not been fully considered. Just because this project is on the bayfront does not mean the effects of this project will not be to the detriment of the neighborhood directly to the west of it. To my knowledge, no environmental studies have been done. Has BCDC rendered an opinion?
The land’s owner, The State Lands Commission, is not mentioned on the operating plans. This begs the question, “How will success be measured and monitored? And what happens if it doesn’t meet the criteria for success?” Who is left holding the bag? Who will step up if this project has a shortfall? Will the land return to a fallow 10 acres and sit for another 40 or 50 years as it already has, becoming an underutilized property along the Burlingame Bayfront?
Years ago, the city entered into a lease agreement with a private company to manage the Golf Driving Range where Top Golf is today. The revenues were inadequate and closure was eminent. A new very favorable lease with a new operator was agreed upon in order to keep the doors open. The lesson here is that the city could control the outcome to a certain degree. The Bay Rise Park project, on the other hand, eliminates the city from influencing the project in any way, instead SPHERE will operate by its own rules and standards with no city oversight. This should be a red flag for our city. At the very least, an oversight committee should be considered.
Perhaps the question should be, “Who is The SPHERE Institute? According to a search on the internet its budget has been as high as $38 million in 2021, its CEO makes $640K per year. What’s difficult to find is where the funding of the institute comes from in the first place.
Another obvious question is, why do they want to embark on a project like this that they have zero experience with and are looking to fund the operation, not out of their annual budget, like some of their other endeavors, but rather fund it through the leasing of a building on the grounds of Bay Rise Park? It’s important to some that the funds that will help to make this park a reality aren’t subject to disappear depending on the winds of change. Has anyone asked these questions before shaking hands on an agreement?
To date, to my knowledge, there has not been a pro-forma presented. How much will it cost to build and operate? How much revenue will the event center have to generate and how often would it have to be rented in order to cover the annual costs? Projected numbers are important. The fact that this project has been in the development stages for 7 years without any real projected numbers may indicate that SPHERE is ill-prepared to operate such a magnanimous effort.
The restoration of our wetlands, the improving of access to the bay and education for the public and more open space to enjoy all sound good. But, it can all go sideways very quickly if we don’t ask the tough questions, even at this late stage of the project’s development.
Someone, the press, the state lands commission, the state treasurer, the state attorney general? Someone needs to look into who SPHERE is or it may be too late. Here is the proposed building.
One of the main reasons to read the SF Comicle is to find little nuggets of information amid all the gibberish that actually have value if thought about properly. Today’s front page piece on a data center moratorium in EssEff has just such a nugget.
A new report on the potential impacts of data centers on San Francisco is likely to guide imminent decisions faced by city leaders on whether to embrace a permanent ban of the controversial facilities. The extension of a 45-day moratorium for another 10½ months will be considered by a Board of Supervisors committee next week in the wake of the city analysis of data centers released Tuesday. If the full board approves the extension, the ban could then be drawn out for another two years.
The city report, issued at the direction of Mayor Daniel Lurie’s administration, warns that large data centers could compete with housing, hospital, businesses and other development for limited electricity capacity, while backup generators could contribute to noise and air pollution in neighborhoods already facing environmental burdens. The report states that a 50-megawatt data center could consume as much electricity as 25,000 new homes, and that the city is already nearing its transmission capacity.
Whoa. Hold the electrons. If the city is “nearing its transmission capacity” then why are tens of thousands of new units being planned and built? Giant project at the Marina Safeway? Skyscrapers in the Sunset? RHNA numbers that boggle the mind. San Francisco’s Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) for the 2023–2031 cycle requires the city to plan for and facilitate the creation of 82,069 new housing units.
Remind me again of when the Bay Area Airhead Board says we all need to switch to electric hot water heaters. Oh yeah, January 2028. There are some short-circuited people in elected and appointed positions.
Last night Sapore celebrated its 25th anniversary with the blow-out party of the year. At least 300 people filled the restaurant, the sidewalk and extra tables set outside as Elio and team were feeling the love. A Who’s Who of locals and a few non-B’gamers (mostly politicians) showed up to hear the speeches and cut the ribbon with the giant scissors.
Since it was hosted by the Chamber of Commerce, CEO Susan Baker kicked it off followed by Mayor-for-another-month Michael Brownrigg. Michael compared Sapore owner and Citizen of the Year Elio D’Urzo to a Ferrari. Fast, beautiful and, per some at the city, a lot of maintenance required. It was all in good fun with a speck of truth to it. He noted that he had cut many ribbons in town but had never had as many people behind him as in front of him. Elio said a few warm words punctuated with arm-waving, but the speech of the night was an impromptu accolade from long-time server Sahara. She noted how Elio has a personal relationship with everyone who was there (all 300+) and was by far the best boss she has ever had taking an interest in her and her family. It was a tear-jerker and I can’t really do it justice— you had to be there. Perry D’Andrea did his best Frank Sinatra schtick while food and drink flowed all night as it usually does and everyone had a blast. Here’s the crowd>
Here is a great story for our second Fall TreeHugger post of the season courtesy of the Wall Street Journal. I don’t know the author, Betsy Corcoran, but I have it on good authority that she is a Burlingamer. The full-page piece is headlined “We Drove 3,900 Miles From San Francisco to Boston With Seven Giant-Sequoia Seedlings.” Betsy relays the story of her and her husband marveling at the Giant Sequoias to the point where
Rangers frown on taking even a stick from a national park. Still, I needed a reminder of these groves’ peacefulness and strength. I slipped a few of the marshmallow-size sequoia cones into my pocket. A year later, they released seeds, which I decided to try to germinate. It worked. Fast-forward four years: I had nurtured nine baby giant sequoias that were now outgrowing their large plastic buckets. I planted two in my tiny backyard—perhaps a bit ambitious given how large these trees could get if they survive, say, 1,000 years. (If they last even 100, they will likely outlast my house.)
But the rest of the trees? I wanted them to go to people who meant something to me. My brother, Chris Corcoran, who lives outside Boston, loved the idea. He wanted a tree, no questions asked. His enthusiasm inspired me: Why not take a road trip, with trees? As friends heard about our evolving plans, they began raising their hands.
And so the story went. She had to get a “phytosanitary certificate” to transport them out of state and deal with a variety of other details like
Traveling with trees is a bit like traveling with puppies, minus the poop bags. We overnighted in places where we could take the trees out of the van, water them and give them a couple of hours of light. Whenever we glanced in the rear view mirror, we could see the trees gently waving their tiny branches in sync with the motion of the van. Our destinations included family and friends in places as diverse as Salt Lake City, Oconomowoc, Wis., Chicago, Maryland, and the Eastern seaboard: Connecticut, Rhode Island and Massachusetts.
It’s a great story and if you are a WSJ subscriber click on through. I sure hope the US Forestry Service hasn’t shown up at her house.
“If you like your gas water heater, you can keep it”
Yesterday the Daily Post and the DJ both had front page pieces about the Bay Area Air Board meeting that County Supe Ray Mueller walked out after twenty minutes. The meeting was closely watched by a number of constituencies as the original plan was to ban new and replacement gas water heaters come January. Mueller felt “boxed in” because the staff only offered two options–stick with the January 2027 deadline or extend a year to January 2028. No option to just dump the idea altogether. He feels the cost estimates are vague. He noted “I don’t think you can move forward with rulemaking that is going to put costs on consumers when you haven’t done a fair assessment of what those costs are”. Lately they gave been throwing around the number $3,500–supposedly $600 to $1,600 more than a replacement water heater. In a lot of cases, that is just laughable.
We touched on some of the issues here and in 2020 here. The more we learn by talking to real plumbers, electricians, and general contractors, the more ridiculous this ban is revealed to be. For example, HVAC guys will tell you that an electric heat pump gets its heat from the air space around it so if you have a water heater indoors, like a service porch or closet, it’s taking living space heat to heat water if you even have enough ambient temperature to make it “efficient”.
Nibbling around the edges by saying people can get an exemption for this or that ignores the time and energy wasted on dealing with a bureaucracy. And saying if one is low-income, they get an exception feels like a “stick it to the middle class” moment. The Board sans Mueller voted to push the deadline out to January 2028 so if you like your current system you can painlessly replace it for another 13 months. Kudos to Ray Mueller for a flash or realism.
The news that the Barrelhouse is closing as the owners focus on a new EssEff spot and the Vinyl Room, which they also own, got me thinking about the various restaurants and bars on the Avenue. Walking over last night (a Thursday about 7:30–prime time), I noticed at least six employees in Five Guys–way more than the number of customers. It never seems even half full. Similarly, Asian Box and Joe and the Juice were nearly empty. It’s not a general Avenue issue as old standbys Mediterranean Kabob and Mingalaba were packed. Crepevine and Sapore are also generally packed and Blue Line Pizza does a nice business whenever I’m there. Joe and the Juice was closed forever for remodeling but that doesn’t seem to have given them a leg up over the other six or seven coffee places on the Ave. It feels like something is going to give with the less popular spots.
I did not think this sole council race was going to be this decisive. The various powers that be were aligned pretty evenly, but as of 8:15 pm tonight on the first vote release, this one ain’t close. We will dig into some of the details in the coming weeks, but for now kudos to Howard and thanks to Jen for throwing her hat in the ring. The other two B’game districts slept through this election as Lorin Flynn noted below–Snoozeville. It will be interesting to see how his mandate plays out against…well, lesser mandates on the dais. Why do I say that? Turnout in D3 was 68% higher than D5 and Wettan out polled both Stevenson and Pappajohn in absolute numbers per the 8:15 drop here:
I like bringing discussions I have off-line, i.e. in real life, onto the Voice for wider disemination. This is the second time someone has offered to put their thoughts down on paper as a Guest Author. The last one was in May here.
As the campaigning for the Nov. 3 election is now just about over, I have an observation: An election where two candidates are running against each other for a single position produces much more intense campaigning than if you are asked to vote for several at-large candidates.
I live in Burlingame District 3, and we have two candidates running against each other for a single seat on the City Council. You should see my mailbox! It has been filled with flyers for the past 4 weeks. And most lawns in District 3 are sporting a sign for one candidate or the other. In contrast, the other Burlingame Districts are snoozeville. Residents are either not voting at all because their district councilmember is not up for re-election this time around, or their existing council member is running unopposed. Only District 3 has any kind of contest.
The change from citywide (at-large) elections to district-based City Council elections happened in 2022. If you want to learn more about why that change was made, you can read about it here: https://www.burlingame.org/220/District-Elections.
Thanks, Lorin. I particularly like the lawns that sport signs for both Faber and Wettan–split households! I also miss seeing some local political mailers rather than just the statewide ones. But none of that can remove the feeling that my vote has been suppressed by 80%. One vote every four years instead of five. That and the huge number of unopposed council races (the DJ’s Mark Simon put it at 16 of 29 seats–55%) is frankly undemocratic in the sense that we either can’t vote or don’t have a choice of candidates.
We haven’t had a good parking shenanigans post since last December’s compact iNDiE camper here. But this just in: the new compact Cybertruck was also spotted at Safeway! It may even be in the same spot. Oddly enough the compact model looks to be the same 18.6 feet long as the original model. At least its solid stainless steel doors can’t get dinged by someone in the adjacent spot.
The Burlingame Voice is dedicated to informing and empowering the Burlingame community. Our blog is a public forum for the discussion of issues that relate to Burlingame, California. Opinions posted on the Burlingame Voice are those of the poster and commenter and not necessarily the opinion of the Editorial Board. Comments are subject to the Terms of Use.