Dedicated to Empowering and Informing the Burlingame Community

Mercury Times' columnist John Horgan has netted out the high-cost rail situation quite nicely here.  The essence of it is

Caltrain, which relies on heavy subsidies from three counties for its day-to-day functions, is a relatively successful transit setup. Can you imagine what the taxpayers will be responsible for if high-speed rail ever graces this area and other parts of California?

Every unbiased analysis of HSR's projected operating costs indicates deep and abiding deficits as far as the eye can see. Who will have to pick up those ongoing costs? We will.

Which is why San Mateo County critics of HSR tend to miss the point. They constantly clamor to have HSR "done right" along the same corridor used by Caltrain.

But, using every available objective study published so far, it can't be. It's a false premise.

High-speed rail is a guaranteed financial loser just waiting to saddle the state's taxpayers with one more unbearable burden, not to mention the eventual cost of servicing the debt imposed by the construction itself. After all, bond dollars aren't free.

You can read parts 1 to 45 by clicking here, but this is the bottom line and it's all RED.

Posted in ,

3 responses to “High-Cost Rail Part 46 – Horgan Nails the Issue”

  1. Joe

    Speaking of good round-ups on the HSR issue, here is another one published today
    http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/261624/bullet-train-bankruptcy-lou-dolinar?page=1

  2. pat giorni

    You write the letter, I’ll buy the stamp.
    March, 2011 | Issue 37
    http://www.asm.ca.gov/Harkey
    Assemblymember.Harkey@assembly.ca.gov
    Good News on High-Speed Spending
    As part of my SOS (Save Our State) effort, High-Speed Rail popped to the fore due to the potential for future huge amounts of debt and financial obligations we would need to undertake at the state and local level, to fund a statewide rail system with no cost controls or monitoring. I have introduced AB 76 this year in an attempt to remove the unused portion of the $9.95B bond (state debt) from our books.
    While last year I was alone in my endeavor to derail this train wreck, I have plenty of company this year. As elected officials have discovered more about this boondoggle, they have joined the fight, at the local, State and now at the Federal level. Congressional Republicans representing us in CA, are unwilling to get on board and allocate stimulus dollars (“free money”) that other states have rejected, to California. We owe Reps. Kevin McCarthy, John Campbell and a new member, Jeff Denham a huge thank you for remembering where they came from and caring about the future of our tarnished, Golden State.
    SOS…We need your help to derail the high speed marketing machine, so please contact your local, county, state and federal elected officials and ask them to support AB76.

  3. Joe

    And another interesting data point I just saw in the Jan 29th issue of The Economist. They were talking about President Obama’s State of the Union address and the goal of bringing high-speed rail to 80% of Americans. The suggestion was that it will “cost much” because
    “The Federal government’s record suggests the money may not be well spent: a report by the World Economic Forum puts America 68th in the world for effectiveness of it public-sector spending.”
    Sigh.

Leave a Reply


The Burlingame Voice is dedicated to informing and empowering the Burlingame community.  Our blog is a public forum for the discussion of issues that relate to Burlingame, California.  Opinions posted on the Burlingame Voice are those of the poster and commenter and not necessarily the opinion of the Editorial Board.  Comments are subject to the Terms of Use.


All content subject to Copyright 2003-2026

Discover more from The Burlingame Voice

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading