Dedicated to Empowering and Informing the Burlingame Community

I just hung out my Italian flag to honor Columbus Day today.  In view of what South San Francisco's city council did back on Aug. 26th cancelling the observance of the day, I wanted to register my protest on my porch and on the Voice.  There is a famous arm movement used by Italian drivers, especially in Rome, that applies here in my opinion.  But let's just review some of the history that myopic public officials are trying to cancel.  From today's Wall Street Journal piece by Alessandra Bocchi

Columbus Day became a national holiday in the U.S. in 1968 thanks in part to the lobbying efforts of Italian-Americans.  Italian immigrants, most of whom came from Naples and Sicily, faced severe discrimination in the 19th century. “They were heavily exploited, and in some instances they were paid less than ‘white’ and ‘colored’ labor—for instance in the work on New York’s Croton Reservoir,” says Seton Hall historian William Connell, author of “The Routledge History of Italian Americans.”

That wasn’t the worst of it. In 1899 the New York Sun described the “unwritten law of the south,” under which “white men could not be lynched—with the exception of the Italian.” Italian-Americans were the target of the biggest lynching in American history, in New Orleans in 1891. After the police chief of New Orleans was shot, hundreds of Sicilian immigrants were rounded up without cause, and nine were tried for murder. The jury acquitted them, but Mayor Joseph A. Shakespeare organized a mob of between 8,000 and 20,000, which stormed the prison and murdered the nine men and two other Sicilians who were held for unrelated charges.

A future president was among those cheering on the mob. “Personally I think it rather a good thing,” Theodore Roosevelt wrote to his sister. The New York Times editorialized: “These sneaking and cowardly Sicilians, the descendants of bandits and assassins . . . are to us a pest without mitigations.”

In 1925 the Ku Klux Klan opposed an effort to erect a statue of Columbus in Richmond, Va. The Klan lost the argument, and the monument was dedicated in December 1927.

So the South San Francisco council stands with the KKK and numerous other racists.  Frankly the ones who voted to do this should resign in disgrace.  They probably wouldn't try to drive to the East Bay without GPS and Waze never mind get in a little ship and sail to the end of the earth where common belief said they would fall off.  Basta.

Posted in ,

36 responses to “Columbus Day Thoughts”

  1. Really

    This is the kind of pretzel logic it takes the winner to convince themselves they are the oppressed. Wtf.

  2. Joe

    Those who forget history are doomed to repeat it. Really. Deal with it.

  3. wtf

    Hey Joe — can you name the Indigenous Peoples that first lived in the area that is now known as San Mateo County? And what methods were used to push them out, kill them, and erase them from history?

  4. Joe

    Sure. Can you tell me what year Columbus came to San Mateo County? Didn’t think so, idiot.

  5. wtf – I signed up for Nextdoor after hearing about the tree falling in Washington Park.
    It is incredible what younger people are posting there. If children are our future I am afraid we are in deep doo-doo.
    For example, one young person posted this bio: “Just wading my way through the field guide of suburban racism that is Burlingame on Nextdoor.”
    Back to topic. Let me point out that Spanish were here after the Ohlone. Then it was the Mexicans. Then it was the Europeans.
    Many seem to want to forget about the first two and blame everything on the Europeans.

  6. MAGA

    Keep in mind if the left wins in a few weeks this Columbus Day in America (never mind SSF) will have been the last one.

  7. Wunderkind

    My DNA has been in North America about 400 years. Part Wampanoag. Chief had the rather uninspiring name of Old Chicken Warrup.
    Martha’s Vineyard was part of our territory. Thinking about asking the Obama family for Hyannisport reparations.
    Chances?

  8. No Wokester

    The wokester snowflakes don’t handle confrontation very well. If they have a mask and a frozen water bottle they get ballsy. No mask, no real history, no argument.
    The SSF racists are a moment in time. Like fake Catholic Nancy “statues don’t matter to me” Pelosi. The KKK hated Catholics more than blacks. The old term was papists and they hunted them. We will see it in 2020 this week with the Supreme Court hearings. Things don’t change much. The wokesters will grow up and be embarrassed by their woke ignorance.

  9. Sign Me Up

    If South SF wanted an Indigenous Day they should declare one that isn’t Columbus Day and leave Columbus Day alone. Yelp just added a racist button to their reviews. Maybe we need to review SSF as racist.

  10. 4th grade flashbacks

    @Paloma Ave.: Was Spain voted out of Europe and I somehow missed it?
    Also, just for the record: Europeans didn’t move in after the Mexicans (unless you count the small Russian attempt at Ft. Ross from 1812-1841)…but the Americans sure did.

  11. BillyGBob

    Joe, Columbus sailed west to reach Asia because he knew the Earth was round (which had pretty much been established 2,000 years before and, by the 15th Century, was common knowledge amongst anyone with the means to fund or undertake such a voyage). But don’t let facts get in the way of an attempt to be snarky.

  12. Joe

    BGB, don’t worry. I won’t >wink<. C'mon, man, that's a really good line and you know it! Well, there's theory and there is experience. Magellan didn't leave for his circumnavigation until 1519 and didn't get back to tell anyone about it for 3 years. BTW, Columbus' greatest feat might have been to do the whole trip on OPM (from Spain). Anyway you look at it, the sad virtue-signallers in SF and SSF are a disgrace.

  13. BillyGBob

    Actually, I disagree. I have no problem with a jurisdiction not wishing to recognize Columbus Day. It has nothing to do with being anti-Italian or anti-Catholic. It has everything to do with being anti-dude-who-enslaved-thousands-and-opened-door-for-genocide. Recognizing Italian and Catholic contributions to the US is great. Just pick someone else (Philip Mazzei or Bartolome de las Casas, for example).

  14. 4th grader – Are you unaware of the term “Latinx”?
    Apparently they want to be considered different from white Europeans.

  15. No Wokester

    It looks like Joe has exposed a wokester or two. They are experts at seeing systemic racism in others but avoid the mirror. They love to tell others how to think and who is and isn’t OK to honor. Very wokester-ish

  16. Libertarian

    America is the least racist country that has ever existed in the world’s history.
    That is a fact that is undeniable.
    Is it perfect yet, no.
    Is it the best ever, yes.
    Try being white in Mexico.
    Try being non-Chinese in China.
    Try attempting to climb the economic and social ladder in France without being a French origin citizen.
    The list goes on and on.
    Why is America the first priority for the world to seek entry?
    The Marxist leftists want to destroy the world’s most sought sanctuary.
    How sad, but defining of their lack of integrity, honesty and knowledge.

  17. BillyGBob

    Using the term “Marxist leftist” in this topic shows one or more of the following: (a) you have no idea what it is; (b) you do, but assume other readers on this forum don’t; and/or (c) you couldn’t care less either way, but you really like the dopamine hit you get when others respond appropriately from getting their right-wing, centrist, or left-wing buttons pushed. The rest of the comment reads like a typical troll-bot rant generator, or an RT/OAN script.

  18. Barking Dog

    BGB, so its safe to say your comments read like a CNN, MSNBC, DSA, Mike Dunham/Jordan Grimes/Cindy Cornell/Peninsula for Everyone script, correct?

  19. The quarantine got you feeling ornery, Joe?
    What’s next: an All Lives Matter post?
    Trolling your readers isn’t very neighborly.

  20. Barking Dog

    All Lives dont matter to you Fugit?
    Is it racist trope if it is said?
    Your a buffoon.

  21. YOU’RE a buffoon.
    Corrected it for ya, BD.

  22. Barking Dog

    Thanks for the grammer correction, appreciate it.
    YOU’RE a buffoon.

  23. Joe

    I guess trolling is in the eyes of the fish.
    It’s Columbus Day, it will always be Columbus Day and the little cancellers will just have to deal with it.

  24. oh well

    Well this little blog sure has sunk to a new low. Seems like no one can voice an intelligent thought or viewpoint without quickly resorting to name calling. Hmmm, I wonder who has emboldened that behavior?

  25. resident

    Fugit All. But you can’t be surprised.

  26. Too Much Edukation

    My academic achievements in political economy and political science are quite good. 3.6 GPA. I admit it was all a bit textbook at the time. Lately the lessons are bubbling up from my memory. I would be very curious to hear exactly what the hell BillyBob is talking about when he claims distance between Marxism and Leftists. I am all ears.

  27. Joe

    We are a week away from Columbus Day and the Millbrae city council has this to say https://bit.ly/3A4hRuE:
    In other business, the (Millbrae) council approved a new flag policy for those flown on city flag poles.
    The new policy will allow for flags representing Black History Month in February, Asian Pacific Islander Heritage Month in May, Pride Month in June, Hispanic Heritage Month in September, Native American Heritage Month in November, as well as Memorial Day and Veterans Day.
    —————–
    Do you see anything missing for October?

  28. Cassandra

    E pluribus unum
    The flag thing gets this exactly wrong.

  29. Joe

    Happy Columbus Day everyone. Here are some thoughts provided by the Conference of Presidents of Major Italian American Organizations (www.copomiao.org)
    Columbus Condemned Slavery – He never bought, sold or owned any slaves
    Columbus Championed Indigenous Rights – He protected Tainos from the Caribs and Canibs that practiced slavery and human sacrifice.
    Columbus never tortured the native populations – this is a lie in the book by Howard Zinn.
    There is plenty more at the web site noted above. Check it out. Ciao.

  30. Christopher Cooke

    Hey Joe, Gary Kasparov, the chess champion, Russian dissident and human rights activist, has a guest column in the WSJ published 10/10 that you might enjoy.

  31. Christopher Cooke

    On Columbus and why he should be recognized with a holiday (sorry I posted too soon)

  32. Joe

    Thanks, Christopher. I read Kasparov’s piece while traveling that day and forgot to double back with a few snippets. Here are a couple:
    His incredible feats of exploration were due to individual qualities that Americans should find admirable, and once did in near unanimity. Holding historical figures to modern standards of morality is a method of anti-historical political control—much like the pseudohistory I grew up being taught in the Soviet Union.
    Columbus taught himself Latin to study ancient and medieval manuscripts for clues about the circumference of the globe and his prospective journeys. True, his calculations were wildly off, overestimating the size of Asia and underestimating the size of the globe. But he also knew that he had to make the mission sound easier, like any startup seeking venture capital. Columbus yearned to fulfill the prophecy of Seneca’s Medea: “An age will come after many years when the Ocean will loose the chains of things, and a huge land lie revealed.” And so he did, in four remarkable voyages that charted and changed the world.
    Revisionism has a vital role in history, as we discover new information and apply new insights to past events. There should be no place for whitewashing and jingoism in the service of a supposedly patriotic agenda—or any agenda. We must teach the good and the bad of our leaders, our founders, our heroes and saints.
    The call for objectivity applies also to those who would judge a 15th-century European who took outrageous risks and performed incredible feats of exploration to advance modern civilization. Humanism and the Enlightenment were still two centuries away.

  33. Joe

    Happy Columbus Day, everyone. I enjoyed rereading the comments from two years ago and hope you do too.
    Thought for the day: Those who insist on viewing historical figures through today’s lens may find themselves erased sometime in the future.
    Exhibit 1: SF School Board’s attempt to take DiFi name off of an elementary school!
    Ciao.

  34. Guido

    The evidence that the Indigenites are what Biden would call semi-fascists is clear. They didn’t push for their own holiday. They want Columbus Day cancelled. That’s what the semi-fascists do.

  35. Coniq

    It will always be Columbus Day.
    People are looking to divide people anyway they can.
    The Burlingame Library has taken down or will be taking down a banner that hung in the reading room for years. Some people were offended by the phrase “ Burlingame is a special place to live.” There is such a rush to destroy the past. Guess what?Many people think that Burlingame is a special place to live. How is that offensive? The bay area is the capital of woke society.
    I’m sure as I write this somebody is trying to dig up some negative information about Anson Burlingame and there will be a drive to change the name of our “special” town.

  36. Joe

    Happy Columbus Day 2023 everyone. Here is another snippet from the COMMISSION FOR SOCIAL JUSTICE of the Order Sons and Daughters of Italy in America:
    For Italian Americans, as well as other immigrant groups, who came over as oppressed masses in
    the early 20th century, it was Columbus who served as their champion and gave them hope of a new life,
    one with opportunity. Thus, for Americans of Italian descent, Columbus Day serves as an opportunity to
    celebrate our ancestors and the struggles they overcame to assimilate into American culture. It is unjust to
    take away the symbol of their very identity and the contributions they have made since the early 1900s.
    The false narrative disguised as historical facts surrounding Christopher Columbus and his
    colonization of the Americas was a push as I understand by Native American groups to demonize
    Columbus as a slave trader who spread disease among the indigenous peoples. They proclaim the same
    skewed arguments that Howard Zinn (a person who hated America) presented in his one-sided tale of
    Columbus in A People’s History of the United States. Zinn’s story, as well as the story of the modern-day
    American Indian, presents an overly simplistic view that is completely out of context to the time in which
    he lived. The Indigenous population participated in slavery, and were among the largest slave owners
    during the Civil War. Why are they not being condemned? Surely you realize the conundrum of applying
    a 21st century understanding of morality to the people of the 15th century.

Leave a Reply


The Burlingame Voice is dedicated to informing and empowering the Burlingame community.  Our blog is a public forum for the discussion of issues that relate to Burlingame, California.  Opinions posted on the Burlingame Voice are those of the poster and commenter and not necessarily the opinion of the Editorial Board.  Comments are subject to the Terms of Use.


All content subject to Copyright 2003-2026

Discover more from The Burlingame Voice

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading