This Monday, the planning commission will discuss the fate
of a home located at 1540 Newlands Avenue. It was purchased several months ago
for over 2 million (there are two houses on a double lot.)
Some in the community, including myself, believe that this
home has some significance and shouldn’t be demolished.
To abide by state law, the home had to undergo a historic
survey to determine whether it had historical significance.
I have read the staff report that all commissioners will see
before Monday night’s hearing and the official report has determined that there
is no architectural nor cultural significance for listing on a National
registry or state list. Perhaps it could be listed locally, but Burlingame has
no such list, unlike many surrounding communities.
In the report, it states that this home was typical of the
homes built in the area during the 1920’s and 30’s.
That couldn’t be further from the truth. According to
documentation provided by the family that commissioned the building of the
home, the home’s cost was double that of a typical home in the neighborhood.
Drive by today and you will see that this house clearly
stands out from the surrounding homes in the area, which typically are
one-story bungalows. This home is not a craftsman bungalow, it would be
considered neo classical. There are no other homes near this one that compare.
The report also suggests that the architect that built the
house was influential and the man who lived in the house after it was built was
of local prominence. (Perhaps I will write more about that later).
To me, beyond the architectural and cultural significance,
this seems like a really nice house, (two of them actually). Why would anyone
want to tear them down? It seems a shame to me.
Anyone agree? Disagree?
Planning Commission meeting begins at 7pm, City Hall Council Chambers, Monday, August 9th.
Below is a sketch of one of the houses proposed for this lot.